On This Date: Pete Rose Passes Ty Cobb — Two Men Who Played the Game the Same Way (Sept. 11, 1985)

On this date in 1985, at 8:01 on a Wednesday night at Riverfront Stadium, Pete Rose took a 2-1 slider from Eric Show of the Padres and lined it into left-center field. It was career hit number 4,192, one more than Ty Cobb. The 47,237 people in the building stood and roared for roughly seven minutes. A red Corvette rolled in from behind the outfield fence. And the man who had spent 23 seasons refusing to show anybody anything stood at first base and cried on his first-base coach's shoulder.

"I'm not smart enough to have the words to describe my feeling," he said afterward. "I didn't know what to do."

It was the most-hits-ever record. But it was never really about the hits.

Charlie Hustle

Start with the nickname, because it was meant as an insult. In the spring of 1963, a rookie nobody had heard of drew a walk in an exhibition game against the Yankees and sprinted to first base. Whitey Ford, watching from the other dugout, sneered, "Charlie Hustle." (Mickey Mantle told it differently: Ford said it after Rose climbed the outfield fence trying to catch a Mantle homer that was a hundred feet over his head.) Either way, it was two Hall of Famers laughing at a kid for trying too hard. Rose kept the name for 62 years.

He ran to first on every walk. He slid headfirst into every base — "because it's the fastest way to get there," he explained that night in 1985. "It's probably the safest, too." In the 1970 All-Star Game, with the game meaning nothing, he ran over catcher Ray Fosse at the plate to score the winning run in the 12th inning. In the 1973 playoffs he slid into second base so hard that Bud Harrelson came up swinging, and the two of them started a brawl that emptied both benches at Shea.

None of it was for show. Rose was not the most gifted player of his era, and he knew it. He was a singles hitter with an average arm who played wherever the team needed a body — second base, left, right, third, first — and made 17 All-Star teams at five different positions, which nobody else has done. He was Rookie of the Year in 1963, MVP in 1973, and World Series MVP in 1975. He hit in 44 straight games in 1978, still the National League record. He played in more games and took more at-bats than anyone in history.

And above everything else, he won. The Big Red Machine won the World Series in 1975 and 1976 with Rose as its engine. When he left for Philadelphia, a franchise that had never won anything, the Phillies won the World Series in his second year there. Nobody in the history of the game played in more winning games than Pete Rose.

Birds of a Feather

The next morning's papers made the connection without being asked. "Ty Cobb and Pete Rose," the Quincy Patriot Ledger's sports editor wrote. "Birds of a feather."

They were. Cobb was the meanest competitor of his era, a man who ran the bases with his spikes up and treated every game as a fight. He hit .366 for his career and got on base more than 4,000 times because he refused to give away a single at-bat. Rose studied him. He liked to tell the story of Cobb, long retired, sitting in the wrong dugout at Yankee Stadium, waiting for the Yankees to finish batting practice, then strolling out and hitting the first 15 pitches he saw into the seats. Rose understood that man completely.

Cobb's final hit came on Sept. 3, 1928, a pinch-hit double in Washington in a game his team was losing badly, and the local paper didn't even put it in the headline. (We told that story here.) Fifty-seven years later to the day, Rose tied him. That is the kind of detail both men would have appreciated.

The Wrong Night

One footnote the Corvette obscured. Cobb's official 4,191 contains a 1910 clerical error, a two-hit game the American League counted twice. Researchers found it in 1981; the commissioner declined to fix it. By the corrected count of 4,189, Rose had actually passed Cobb three days earlier, on Sept. 8 at Wrigley Field, with a first-pitch single in a game suspended for darkness at 5-5 and never finished. Nobody in the park knew. Rose, who never in his life took one hit when two were available, got two out of one record.

The Fall

Four years after the Corvette, it came apart. In 1989 an investigation led by John Dowd documented that Rose had bet on baseball, including on his own Reds, while he was managing them. On Aug. 24, 1989, he accepted permanent ineligibility in an agreement with Commissioner Bart Giamatti; Rose gave up his lawsuit, and baseball made no formal finding. Eight days later Giamatti died of a heart attack. In 1991 the Hall of Fame changed its rules to exclude anyone on the ineligible list, and the game's all-time hit leader was locked out of Cooperstown.

Rose denied it for 15 years. In 2004 he admitted it. He died on Sept. 30, 2024, at 83, still banned. Eight months later, Commissioner Rob Manfred ruled that permanent ineligibility ends at death and removed him from the list, opening a Hall of Fame door that had been shut for 36 years.

The two men at the top of the all-time hits list played the game the same way: every at-bat a fight, every base earned, nothing given away. One of them has been in Cooperstown since the first class. The other was the best player who never got in — and now, maybe, will.

Does Pete Rose belong in the Hall of Fame? Comments below.